Find articles from current/past issues. Find articles from current/past issues.
AARP Segunda Juventud - Welcome
Welcome!englishespañol
Find articles from current/past issues.
Home
games
food
presence
rx drugs
Social Security
trends
health
Finance
travel
sports
entertainment
contact us
AARP Segunda Juventud Reader Services
AARP en español
AARP Puerto Rico

 

ADVERTISEMENT

 



Photo: Susan Scafati 

A Culture of Silence

By Irene S. Levine
February/March 2006

sites to see: bilingual health resources

Two men. Two different stories.

“It happened all of a sudden,” says Alberto Trujillo, a 75-year-old retired mechanic from Clint, Texas. “I couldn’t do anything. I couldn’t think, write, or drive. I didn’t go out of the house. I stayed away from church.” His wife, Mary, had him hospitalized.

For Rodolfo Palma-Lulión, 28, of Saline, Michigan, “it happened over several years. I just wasn’t functioning,” he says. “My mind wasn’t working. I was in college at the time, but I couldn’t make it to class.” Although Palma-Lulión didn’t realize what was wrong, his girlfriend demanded he seek help.

Despite the men’s disparate backgrounds, they share a bond: both have suffered from depression. Trujillo, born in the United States, is Mexican American and has seven children. Palma-Lulión, a native of Chile who came to this country at age six, is married, has one child and is expecting a second in February, and works with a community service program at the University of Michigan

Although nearly twice as many women suffer from depression, the disease strikes 7 percent of men—some 6 million—each year, according to the National Institute of Mental Health. This medical condition affects a person’s body, mood, and thoughts. Left untreated, it strips the joy out of life. It can even turn fatal: about 7 percent of depressed men commit suicide.

“Unfortunately, Hispanic men are less likely to be accurately diagnosed or to receive appropriate care,” says Javier Escobar, chair of the psychiatry department at the University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey-Robert Wood Johnson Medical School. In addition, says the Colombian-born doctor, “Latino males tend to present with physical symptoms rather than mental ones.”

For depressed male Hispanics, mental health treatment seems to work as well as it does for rest of the population

Trujillo says he had trouble sleeping and sometimes didn’t feel like eating. Palma-Lulión experienced similar problems.

Says Escobar, “Particularly those men from Puerto Rico and South American countries complain of multiple pains, aches, migraine headaches, joint pain, weakness, and fatigue.” Laboratory tests reveal no cause for these complaints. When the men share their stories, however, they often point to their heart to explain their symptoms, avoiding mention of sadness or nervousness.

Men in different cultures often handle depression differently, says Escobar, and members of the Hispanic population are diverse. Mexican men, for example, are hesitant to talk to a psychiatrist, while Puerto Ricans are more likely to use mental health services.

“Hispanic men are more likely to seek out the clergy or a spiritual healer, a curandero,” says Gustavo Alva, an associate professor at the University of California-Irvine Department of Psychiatry and Human Behavior. “There is a whole slew of barriers [to treatment].” Alva lists unfamiliarity with the languages and economic difficulties among the top obstacles. And in what researchers call the “Latino paradox,” mental disorders appear less often among Hispanics born outside the United States.

“Medicine and God got me out,” says Trujillo, but it took four and a half years after his hospitalization for his doctors to come up with the right drug combination.

The difficulty of finding medication that works is exacerbated by another problem. "Overall, these men are much less likely to participate in psychotherapy or to take antidepressants when they are prescribed,” says Escobar. One common side effect of the medications, sexual dysfunction, is particularly difficult for Latin males.

Although the causes of depression are not completely understood, professionals agree that this is a “no-fault” illness that stems from the interplay of genetics and environment rather than from a character flaw. But despite new studies, many people still consider depression a weakness. “Sadly, the majority of Hispanic men with depression are never treated,” says Escobar, although treatment is becoming more acceptable with increased awareness among primary care doctors and new antidepressants.

With treatment, Trujillo has returned to all the things he once enjoyed

Escobar observes that when depressed Hispanic men do appear in clinics—often with the whole family—it’s because one of their children has recognized the symptoms.

In Trujillo’s case, however, his wife, Mary, 70, took action. “He didn’t have much of a say because he was so sick,” she says, recalling how he reached a point where he knew his name but little else. She would even have to comb his hair for him. Still, she says, “Depression was the last thing on my mind because he had been such an active person.”

For depressed male Hispanics, mental health treatment seems to work as well as it does for rest of the population, says Escobar. But he and Alva agree that more research is desperately needed.

“We are dealing with the fastest-growing minority group in the United States, yet most drug trials have been limited to Caucasian families,” Alva says.

With treatment, Trujillo has returned to all the things he once enjoyed: walking, playing golf, eating out, and spending time with his family. “I have to thank my wife and my children,” he says. “They and my belief in God helped turn things around.”

Palma-Lulión also found support around him. “Telling my professors and friends about my illness, I found out that I had more help than I initially thought,” he says.

Especially among Hispanics, he encountered what he calls a “culture of silence” that must change so men can feel comfortable asking for help. “Being Latino makes it different,” he says. “The idea of what it is to be a man is different from the dominant Caucasian society. Latino men don’t have ‘depression.’ They get angry and self-medicate with alcohol; it’s part of being a man.”

He has already begun shattering the silence. “I’m starting to realize that there was depression throughout my family history,” he says. “Seeing my experience with depression has helped change my dad’s perception of the disease.”



For general health information resources, take a look at our list of bilingual sites that cover the full gamut of conditions from asthma to yersinia.

Return to Top


 
 
 
Subscribe
Sign up for the free AARP Segunda Juventud.org eNewsletter
Get the Magazine
Not an AARP member? Join now and start receiving AARP Segunda Juventud magazine at home, plus other great benefits.
Join now »

Already an AARP member? Click here to start receiving AARP Segunda Juventud magazine in your home.

 

 

 


ADVERTISEMENT


www.aarp.org | contact us | privacy policy
copyright 2007, AARP. All rights reserved.