Shifting Gears
By Holly Ocasio Rizzo
Hank Davenport Barberís shopped like a man with a mission when it
was time to replace his outgrown, outworn Nissan pickup truck.
"I wanted a small pickup truck that could pack camping and hiking
gear and tow a boat," says Davenport, 63, of San Diego. "It had to
have a crew cab because my son, a teenager, was getting too big to
fit into a jump seat like the old truck had." The truck also had to
have a standard transmission, security system, and special trim package,
and meet his monthly payment needs.
Three car dealers and a test drive later,
Davenport took home his dream truck-but not without negotiating the
price and arranging financing through his credit union.
Nobody says it's easy to get the best deal on a new car. It can take
several months from picking a model to driving it off the dealer's
lot. But experts agree that homework and planning put savvy buyers
miles, and dollars, ahead.
Sally Hurme of AARP's Consumer Protection office plans to be a savvy
buyer. "I need to buy a new car," she says. "It's a big investment
of time. You must comparison shop, and finding the right car is only
one step."
| ‘Make sure that if you’re
not comfortable with technology, you’re not buying a car
that will intimidate you’ |
Picking the right car
A
good car is a great friend, appealing to the head and the heart. So it's important to look at needs as well as desires. Manufacturers
have begun paying special attention to older drivers' needs. At the
Ford Motor Co., engineers test their designs wearing a "Third-Age Suit" that
simulates the physical needs of people in their 60s and 70s. The suit
was first used to design the 2001 Ford Focus. Ford avoids using red
or blue on dashboard gauges because studies have shown those colors
to be harder for older eyes to see.
Options now include comforts and conveniences that were unheard of
10 years ago. Look for seats that have built-in warmers and lumbar
support; navigation aids that give specific directions and maps; sensors
that beep when a vehicle in reverse gets too close to an object; heads-up
control panels that project the speedometer and other gauges against
the windshield so the driver never needs to take his or her eyes off
the road; and controls that are within easy reach.
General Motors Corp. last fall unveiled its Sit-N-Lift option for
minivans, a motorized seat that rotates out from the vehicle and lowers
for easy access. GM is considering adding more grab handles to some
models to make them easier to get into and out of.
A caution goes along with these conveniences. "Make sure that if you're
not comfortable with technology, you're not buying a car that will
intimidate you," says George Hoffer, an economics professor at Virginia
Commonwealth University who specializes in consumer issues related
to the auto industry.
Some considerations never change. Is the vehicle big enough to carry
the anticipated passengers and cargo? Do the windows provide enough
daytime and nighttime visibility? Will the vehicle fit into a garage
or parking area? What will the cost of ownership be, including insurance,
maintenance, and fuel? Will the car be safe in a crash?
Vehicle design is the most important factor in crash-worthiness, says
the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, an industry-funded agency
that compiles accident data and conducts crash tests. In general, heavier,
larger cars offer better protection than lighter, smaller ones. Air
bags and seat belts generally work well if they fit properly, as do
head restraints, which are mandatory on all new cars.
The best way to buy
Look
for more bilingual salespeople at car dealerships, more buyer's
guides in Spanish and English, and more sales cubicles large enough
to seat entire families.
Why the change? Industry surveys indicate
that more than 13 percent of new-car buyers are Hispanics whose median
household income tops
$47,500. Add census figures that show a growing population of 38 million
Hispanics in the United States, and the market potential looks rosy.
The goal is still to sell cars-lots of them.
Most experts agree that the best time to
shop is at the end of the month, when salespeople are hungry to reach
their monthly quotas. Years
ago, the best times of year to shop were summer and winter, when sales
were slow and deals were abundant. Now, there's no best time of year;
deals arise based on customer rebates and dealer incentives. Rebates
go directly to customers. Incentives are given to dealers by manufacturers
and may be fully or partially passed on to customers.
"Since September 11 [2001], the industry has adopted an attitude of 'Do
what's necessary to sell the car today,'" Hoffer says. He adds, however,
that it has become harder for buyers to negotiate with dealers because
manufacturers have cut the markup percentage to dealers. The dealer
discount for a Lincoln Town Car, for example, was 26 percent in 1977.
Nowadays, it is 11 percent. "In the old days, the dealer had room to
price adjust," Hoffer says. "Today, the manufacturer uses rebates to
adjust the price."
Buyers usually can get the best deals by
shopping themselves rather than online or through a broker. "The basic strategy is to make dealers
bid for your business," says Robert Krughoff, president of Consumers' CHECKBOOK/Center
for the Study of Services, an independent, nonprofit consumer-information
organization based in Washington, D.C. "We don't recommend negotiating.
Negotiating is confrontation, and people don't like that. We recommend
getting competitive bids."
Here's the plan: once you decide on a make, model, and style, don't
talk about the price with a salesman. Go home, call the dealer and
ask to speak with the sales manager. Invite the manager to bid for
your business, telling him or her that you're also extending the invitation
to five other dealers. Ask how much below invoice the dealer is willing
to go.
"Do it all by phone, because it's much more believable that way, that
you'll really go to five other places," Krughoff says. The difference
between negotiating and competitive bidding can be worth more than
$1,000 a car, he says. "When the Acura NSX first came out, we were
getting prices $10,000 lower than customers were offered by a dealer."
Buy or lease?
Experts
agree that in the end, leasing costs more than buying. That's
because with a lease, rather than paying down the principal, the monthly
payments are structured around an estimate of the car's value at
the end of the lease term.
Leasing offers advantages to customers who want to drive a more expensive
car for a lower initial cash outlay and, possibly, a lower monthly
payment; who like to drive a new car every few years; and who want
to avoid the hassle of getting rid of a used car.
But it may be disadvantageous for people who drive more than 15,000
miles a year, who want to modify a vehicle, and who want the flexibility
of selling a car whenever they want.
Not all lease contracts are equal. Variables may include the length
of term, the down-payment amount, the maximum allowable mileage, whether
insurance coverage is included, and the penalties for early termination.
"You have to do the calculations for your individual circumstances,
your needs and use," says Hurme of AARP. "You also must compare leases
from different companies."
From the dealer's perspective, the sales strategy for leases is simple,
Hoffer says: "Every vehicle you lease today guarantees you another
sale in three years."
How will you pay for it?
Some
experts say the simple rule of thumb is your total monthly car payments-for all the cars in the household-shouldn't
exceed 20 percent of your monthly income after taxes.
Calculate before you shop. Several websites offer calculators that
estimate monthly payments based on purchase price, down payment, interest
rate, and length of loan.
And don't fall for dealer come-ons. "The zero percent finance rate
may be zero percent for three months or six months, but then it bumps
up," Hurme says. The lowest rates go to customers with perfect credit,
which few people have. Even opening a new credit-card account can lower
a credit score as much as 12 points.
Hurme recommends lining up financing through a credit union, if possible.
Credit unions offer competitive rates and are more forgiving of poor
credit histories.
Because many Hispanics aren't familiar with
credit, they have no credit history, says Beatriz Juliao-Mauersberg,
Hispanic outreach coordinator
for the Consumer Credit Counseling Service of Greater Atlanta and Palm
Beach County/Treasure Coast. Without a credit history, they often seek
loans at dealerships that also provide financing or they seek them
from storefront lenders charging high interest rates, she adds.
Juliao-Mauersberg urges car buyers to check
their credit history about three or four months ahead of the anticipated
purchase. "That will
give you time to resolve any errors and time to shop for your own financing," she
says.
She warns that all potential lenders check
credit histories. "Every
time you apply for credit and someone checks your credit history, that's
called an inquiry," Juliao-Mauersberg says. "Too many inquiries in
a short period might be negative for the credit score. They could be
seen as too eager to get credit."
Bad credit takes time to repair; bankruptcies,
for example, stay on the record for as long as 10 years in some states.
Buyers with bad
credit should find alternatives to taking out loans for new cars, such
as paying cash for a used car, say both Hurme and Juliao-Mauersberg,
urging such buyers to be realistic. "You don't want a surprise when
you're sitting in front of a banker," Juliao-Mauersberg says.
Remember to insure it
Most states require car owners to carry a minimum amount of liability
coverage. This pays for bodily-injury claims in case of a crash. Liability
insurance is described in two numbers; the first is the maximum coverage
per person and the second is the maximum per accident.
"The minimum to drive legally in most states is very low," says Jeanne
Salvatore, vice president and spokeswoman for the Insurance Information
Institute, a nonprofit educational organization founded by property
casualty companies. "Generally, 100/300 [$100,000/$300,000] is more
realistic, and you may want higher limits, depending on your needs
and financial situation."
Collision and comprehensive coverage are
optional. Collision covers collision damage to your car. Comprehensive
covers non-collision damage
from events such as natural disasters, riots, and theft. You can choose
the deductible but not the price, which is based in part on the car's
sticker price, the cost of repairing it, its overall safety record,
and the likelihood of theft.
Be sure to apply for possible reductions.
These vary among insurers, but may include reductions for having
air bags, anti-lock brakes, and
anti-theft devices in the car; parking in a closed garage; having a
ticket-free driving record; and taking a driver-safety course if you're
over 55. Low-mileage drivers also may qualify for a discount.
Where does a car buyer's ultimate bargaining power lie? Experts
agree: It's the
feet.
"I dug in my heels and told the dealer, 'You'll give me this amount
for my trade-in and match this amount for the new truck's price, or
I'll go home,' " Davenport says. "They knew they had a hot buyer and
they didn't want to let me go." Hurme commented "while paying
cash is a great idea, if someone has bad credit they probably don't
have enough
cash around to buy a car without
a loan. The key point is to line up the financing before shopping for
the car, because dealer financing may be the least attractive option.
People should look for alternatives to loans from dealers.
Now find out what to look for when test
driving a car and get 10
tips to get the best deal on your new car.
Return to Top